Discussion:Loss C-Corp converts to an LLC

From TaxAlmanac, A Free Online Resource for Tax Professionals
Note: You are using this website at your own risk, subject to our Disclaimer and Website Use and Contribution Terms.

From TaxAlmanac

Jump to: navigation, search

Discussion Forum Index --> Advanced Tax Questions --> Loss C-Corp converts to an LLC
Discussion Forum Index --> Tax Questions --> Loss C-Corp converts to an LLC

Kringle (talk|edits) said:

12 November 2009
My client is part of a closely held C-Corp that has been in existence for 8 years and has a NOL of $2M. The C-Corp only exists to hold bare land, and its only expense for the 8 years has been note interest on the land and legal fees (no revenue), hence the large NOL. It also has $2.1M in loans for the land that the new LLC will take over and $178k in loans from shareholders that will be forgiven.

The shareholders decided to go their separate ways and dissolve the C-Corp. The newly formed LLC will assume the outstanding loans and take possession of the land as an asset. As I said, the shareholder have agreed to forgive the loans due to them ($178k). No section 1244 stock.

My questions are these: 1. Can I simply move the land asset and loans over to the new LLC at current book value without any gain/loss? I can't see a way of doing that and having the zeroing journal entry work. 2. What happens to the forgiven shareholder loans - are they ordinary income to the C-Corp? If I do that, only a portion of the NOL from previous years is used to offset this because of Section 382 limits. 3. What becomes of the remaining NOL? Can I attribute some of it to the value of the land upon transfer to maybe offset gains? 4. Do the shareholders receive any taxable income as a result?

Thank you.

KathiJud (talk|edits) said:

12 November 2009
You must book a sale of the land at its current FMV and record gain or loss when compared to its book value. Capital losses are hard to use in a C Corp. The FMV is debited to your equity (distributed to your shareholders as part of the liquidation). Debt against the property is removed from the books by being credited to your equity (also distributed to shareholders)

You may have ordinary COD income from the shareholder loans that can't be repaid. Research that. Sounds like the corp may be insolvent. If not they would be reclassified as a non taxable increase to equity. Then they would be either added basis to the stockholders or separate capital losses on their personal returns.

Unused NOL's would die with the C Corp. The shareholders must have invested most of the cash to fund those expenses so sounds like they have significant stock basis they can't recover (=capital losses)?

Work through the numbers to see if your shareholders received a net gain or loss with the land at FMV less the debt and less their stock basis.

Kringle (talk|edits) said:

12 November 2009
Thank you. I had a feeling that was the answer, I was just hoping it wasn't.

KathiJud (talk|edits) said:

12 November 2009
On further reflection, if seems you have one TP that wishes to move forward with owning this land. Hoping that it will increase in value and someday be sold at an investment property type of profit? Why can't that TP just have the corp redeem the interest of the shareholder that wants out? Keeps the NOL's available for use on that future sale.

Note I am assuming none of this discussion applies to developer status where the land is inventory.

And why wasn't an election made for all those years to capitalize the interest and property taxes into the basis of the land?

Putting the property into a new LLC starts off with newly established FMV value and the debt. No preservation of prior NOL's to deduct if sold with a future rise in value. Payments of interest would be a flow through item to your TP (TP's if multiple). Deduction of that interest on the TP's return is controlled by the purpose of the debt. Investment property? Sch A investment expense allowed to the extent of investment income with potential carryovers. You could also consider making the election to capitalize the interest and taxes to add to the basis of the land.

Kringle (talk|edits) said:

13 November 2009
This is one of those clients that does things without consulting me first. They went ahead and dissolved the corp and told me after. It absolutely would have made more sense to buy the one dissenting TP out and keep the corp going.

Again, the election was never made to capitalize the interest - they were just waiting for the big payoff created by the land sale, in which they would use the losses to offset it. No one thought that they would one day dissolve and lose the NOL's.

Going forward in the new LLC, how is the election to capitalize interest made? This may provide a better tax benefit than simply deducting investment expense on Sch A each year.

KathiJud (talk|edits) said:

14 November 2009
This is from IRS Pub 535:

Carrying Charges Carrying charges include the taxes and interest you pay to carry or develop real property or to carry, transport, or install personal property. Certain carrying charges must be capitalized under the uniform capitalization rules. (For information on capitalization of interest, see chapter 4.) You can elect to capitalize carrying charges not subject to the uniform capitalization rules, but only if they are otherwise deductible.

You can elect to capitalize carrying charges separately for each project you have and for each type of carrying charge. For unimproved and unproductive real property, your election is good for only 1 year. You must decide whether to capitalize carrying charges each year the property remains unimproved and unproductive. For other real property, your election to capitalize carrying charges remains in effect until construction or development is completed. For personal property, your election is effective until the date you install or first use it, whichever is later.

How to make the election. To make the election to capitalize a carrying charge, write a statement saying which charges you elect to capitalize. Attach it to your original tax return for the year the election is to be effective. However, if you timely filed your return for the year without making the election, you can still make the election by filing an amended return within 6 months of the due date of the return (excluding extensions). Attach the statement to the amended return and write “Filed pursuant to section 301.9100-2” on the statement. File the amended return at the same address you filed the original return.

Kringle (talk|edits) said:

17 November 2009
Thank you very much. This site is extremely helpful!

Kevinh5 (talk|edits) said:

17 November 2009
it would seem to be a bit late to amend those 8 year old returns showing an NOL.

JR1 (talk|edits) said:

November 17, 2009
When you say they dissolved it...how? You're the one who liquidates it with IRS, and if they just did something with the state, then reinstate it and keep rolling.

Kevinh5 (talk|edits) said:

17 November 2009
It was like those 'fizzies' in the 1960's and 1970's - you drop a colored alka-seltzer-like tablet in a glass of water and watch while it dissolves and then you have a wonderful fizzy drink

JR1 (talk|edits) said:

November 17, 2009
Those were great. Root beer was my fave.

KathiJud (talk|edits) said:

18 November 2009
Kevin - the OP wasn't asking about making the carrying charges election on any amended corp returns. The question was how to do that for the new LLC that the land got moved to.

To join in on this discussion, you must first log in.
Personal tools